## Facts

- The case concerned the management of a trust established for the benefit of the claimant, Lord Cardigan.
- Mr. Moore was appointed as trustee and responsible for overseeing trust assets, including a substantial estate.
- The claimant alleged the trustee failed to maintain the estate, neglected necessary repairs, failed to secure appropriate insurance, and made poor investment decisions.
- Such acts were claimed to constitute breaches of fiduciary duties, causing significant financial losses to the trust.
- The court assessed the trustee’s actions regarding trust administration and their impact on the estate’s value.

## Issues

1. Whether the defendant’s conduct amounted to a breach of fiduciary duty in the administration of the trust.
2. Whether the claimant's losses were directly attributable to the alleged mismanagement by the trustee.
3. How equitable compensation should be assessed for losses resulting from the breach.
4. Whether there was any contributory negligence by the claimant affecting liability or the quantum of compensation.

## Decision

- The court found that the defendant failed to maintain the estate and make prudent investment decisions, constituting a breach of fiduciary duty.
- The defendant’s conduct did not meet the standard of care required of trustees managing trust assets.
- The court determined that the claimant’s losses, including the decline in estate value and lost income, were directly attributable to the defendant’s mismanagement.
- No contributory negligence by the claimant was found.
- The court awarded equitable compensation based on the estimated costs to restore the estate and the lost income resulting from the breach.

## Legal Principles

- Trustees owe fiduciary duties including the duty to act in good faith, loyalty, and to exercise reasonable care and skill.
- Trustees must act in the best interests of beneficiaries and preserve the value of trust assets.
- Equitable compensation restores beneficiaries to the position they would have been in but for the breach.
- The causal connection between breach and loss is essential in awarding equitable compensation.
- Equitable compensation is compensatory, not punitive, and must reflect actual financial loss.

## Conclusion

The court held the trustee liable for breaches of fiduciary duty and awarded equitable compensation to the claimant for losses caused by mismanagement, reinforcing trustee obligations to act diligently and in beneficiaries’ best interests.


Brudenell-Bruce v Moore [2014] EWHC 3679 (Ch)