## Facts

- Two attorneys operated a Pennsylvania law partnership in 1971–1972, splitting profits two-thirds to Fierro and one-third to Miele.
- The partnership and partners used the calendar year and cash receipts/disbursements method.
- Clients advanced funds for prepaid legal fees and litigation expenses, which the firm deposited into a segregated client trust account as required by professional responsibility rules.
- After services were performed, the firm would transfer the earned portion from the trust account to the partnership’s general account and refund any unearned balance to the client.
- For administrative convenience, the firm made transfers only several times per year and reported as income only amounts actually transferred to the general account.
- At the end of 1972, the trust account held $68,199; $35,623.75 of that amount had been earned in 1972 but not transferred or reported as 1972 income.
- The Commissioner increased 1972 partnership income to include earned amounts received into the trust account in 1972, increasing Fierro’s taxable income by $47,024 and Miele’s by $23,512.
- The case also involved whether $23,572 omitted from 1971 should be accounted for via I.R.C. § 481 and whether Fierro had a deductible business bad debt in 1971.

## Issues

1. Whether a cash-method law partnership may defer income from earned client advances received and held in a client trust account until the year the funds are transferred to the firm’s general account.
2. Whether $23,572 omitted from 1971 must be taken into account in computing 1972 income under I.R.C. §§ 481(a) and 481(b)(1) due to an accounting-method correction.
3. Whether Fierro was entitled to a 1971 deduction for a business bad debt under I.R.C. § 166.

## Decision

- The court held that earned portions of client advances in the trust account were includible in partnership income in the year earned under constructive receipt principles; deferral until internal transfer was not permitted.
- The court applied I.R.C. § 481 to address the prior-year omission, subject to the limitations of § 481(b)(1), in determining the proper 1972 income adjustments.
- The court disallowed Fierro’s claimed 1971 business bad debt deduction.
- The court directed that final deficiency computations be entered under Tax Court Rule 155.

## Legal Principles

- Under the cash method, income is includible when actually or constructively received; constructive receipt exists when funds are available to the taxpayer without substantial restrictions.
- A law firm cannot control the timing of income recognition by delaying internal transfers between accounts where the earned funds are nonrefundable and subject to the firm’s dominion and control.
- Segregating funds in a required client trust account does not, by itself, prevent constructive receipt of amounts that have become earned and unrestricted.
- When correcting an accounting practice that causes omission or duplication of items across years, I.R.C. § 481(a) requires an adjustment in the year of change, with § 481(b)(1) potentially limiting the tax impact from bunching.
- A business bad debt deduction under I.R.C. § 166 requires a proximate relation to the taxpayer’s trade or business; failure to show that nexus results in disallowance.

## Conclusion

The Tax Court held that a cash-basis law partnership must include earned client advances in income when the right to retain the funds becomes fixed and unrestricted, even if the funds remain in a segregated trust account, and it used § 481 to coordinate correction of prior-year omissions while rejecting a claimed business bad debt deduction.


Miele v. Commissioner, 72 T.C. 284 (1979)