Learning Outcomes
After reading this article, you will be able to identify when the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment applies, explain the proportionality principle, and distinguish the constitutional limits on punishments such as life sentences and the death penalty. You will be able to apply these principles to MBE-style questions and avoid common exam pitfalls.
MBE Syllabus
For the MBE, you are required to understand the constitutional limits on criminal punishment. This includes the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment, the proportionality requirement, and the restrictions on capital punishment. You should be able to:
- Recognize when the Eighth Amendment applies to criminal penalties.
- Apply the proportionality principle to sentencing.
- Identify constitutional limits on the death penalty, including for juveniles and those with intellectual disabilities.
- Distinguish between permissible and impermissible punishments under the Eighth Amendment.
- Understand the difference between cruel and unusual punishment and other constitutional protections.
Test Your Knowledge
Attempt these questions before reading this article. If you find some difficult or cannot remember the answers, remember to look more closely at that area during your revision.
-
Which of the following punishments is most likely to violate the Eighth Amendment?
- A $500 fine for shoplifting
- Life imprisonment for a third minor theft under a "three strikes" law
- Death penalty for a non-homicide crime committed by an adult
- Ten years' imprisonment for armed robbery
-
The Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment prohibits:
- All mandatory minimum sentences
- All forms of capital punishment
- Punishments grossly disproportionate to the offense
- All punishments that cause pain
-
The death penalty may constitutionally be imposed on:
- A defendant with intellectual disability
- A juvenile who committed murder at age 17
- An adult convicted of murder, after individualized sentencing
- A defendant convicted of rape where the victim survived
Introduction
The Eighth Amendment prohibits the infliction of "cruel and unusual punishments." This protection applies to criminal penalties imposed by federal and state governments. The Supreme Court has interpreted this clause to require that punishments not be grossly disproportionate to the offense and to set limits on the use of the death penalty. Understanding the scope and application of this protection is essential for the MBE.
Key Term: Cruel and Unusual Punishment The Eighth Amendment prohibition against punishments that are grossly disproportionate, inhumane, or not consistent with evolving standards of decency.
The Scope of the Eighth Amendment
The Eighth Amendment applies only after a person has been convicted of a crime. It does not apply to pretrial detention, civil penalties, or non-punitive government actions. The Amendment restricts the types of punishments that may be imposed and the methods by which they are carried out.
Proportionality Principle
Punishments must not be grossly disproportionate to the seriousness of the offense. While courts rarely strike down sentences under this principle, a penalty that is extreme compared to the crime may be unconstitutional.
Key Term: Proportionality The requirement that a criminal penalty not be grossly excessive in relation to the seriousness of the offense.
Worked Example 1.1
A defendant is convicted of issuing a bad check for $100. The statute mandates a sentence of 25 years to life in prison for any third felony conviction, regardless of the offense. The defendant challenges the sentence as cruel and unusual.
Answer: The court will apply the proportionality principle. While recidivist statutes are generally upheld, a life sentence for a minor, nonviolent offense may be found grossly disproportionate and thus violate the Eighth Amendment.
The Death Penalty
The Supreme Court has held that the death penalty is not per se unconstitutional, but its use is subject to strict procedural and substantive limits.
When the Death Penalty Is Permitted
The death penalty may be imposed only for crimes where the victim dies (i.e., homicide). It cannot be imposed for non-homicide crimes, such as rape, where the victim survives.
Key Term: Capital Punishment The imposition of the death penalty as a criminal sentence, subject to Eighth Amendment restrictions.
When the Death Penalty Is Prohibited
The death penalty cannot be imposed on:
- Defendants who were under 18 at the time of the offense.
- Defendants with intellectual disability.
- Defendants who are insane at the time of execution.
- Crimes where the victim did not die.
Key Term: Intellectual Disability (Eighth Amendment context) A significant limitation in intellectual functioning and adaptive behavior, which bars execution under the Eighth Amendment.
Individualized Sentencing and Safeguards
Before imposing the death penalty, the sentencing authority must consider aggravating and mitigating factors. Mandatory death sentences are unconstitutional. The process must allow for consideration of the defendant's character and the circumstances of the crime.
Worked Example 1.2
A 17-year-old is convicted of murder and sentenced to death. The state statute allows the death penalty for anyone convicted of murder, regardless of age.
Answer: The sentence is unconstitutional. The Eighth Amendment prohibits the execution of offenders who were under 18 at the time of the crime.
Life Without Parole and Other Severe Sentences
Life without parole for non-homicide offenses committed by juveniles is unconstitutional. For adults, severe sentences, including life without parole, are generally upheld unless grossly disproportionate.
Methods of Punishment
The Eighth Amendment also prohibits punishments that involve torture, barbarity, or methods that cause unnecessary and wanton pain. However, the Amendment does not guarantee a painless death.
Worked Example 1.3
A state uses a three-drug protocol for lethal injection. An inmate claims the method causes a risk of pain and seeks to bar its use under the Eighth Amendment.
Answer: The Supreme Court has held that a method of execution is unconstitutional only if it presents a substantial risk of serious harm compared to available alternatives. A mere possibility of pain does not violate the Eighth Amendment.
Exam Warning
The Eighth Amendment does not prohibit all harsh or lengthy sentences. Only punishments that are grossly disproportionate, or that violate specific substantive or procedural limits, will be struck down.
Revision Tip
On the MBE, always check if the punishment is grossly excessive, imposed on a protected class (juvenile, intellectually disabled), or for a non-homicide crime. These are the most common Eighth Amendment issues tested.
Key Point Checklist
This article has covered the following key knowledge points:
- The Eighth Amendment prohibits cruel and unusual punishment after conviction.
- Punishments must not be grossly disproportionate to the offense.
- The death penalty is allowed only for homicide and not for juveniles, intellectually disabled, or insane defendants.
- Life without parole for non-homicide offenses is unconstitutional for juveniles.
- Methods of punishment must not involve unnecessary or wanton pain.
- The Eighth Amendment does not apply to civil penalties or pretrial detention.
Key Terms and Concepts
- Cruel and Unusual Punishment
- Proportionality
- Capital Punishment
- Intellectual Disability (Eighth Amendment context)
