Facts
- Miss Pullan, the plaintiff, was the daughter of Mr. Koe, the defendant.
- Prior to her marriage, Mr. Koe promised Miss Pullan an annual allowance of £100, contingent upon her marrying.
- Miss Pullan relied on this promise when she entered into the marriage.
- After her marriage, Mr. Koe did not fulfill his promise to pay the allowance.
- Miss Pullan brought a legal claim against Mr. Koe to enforce the promise.
Issues
- Whether a father's promise to provide a financial allowance to his daughter, made in contemplation of her marriage, constituted valid consideration under English contract law.
- Whether such a promise was intended to create legal relations or was merely a moral or social obligation.
- Whether the promise was sufficiently clear and specific to be legally enforceable.
Decision
- The court held that Mr. Koe’s promise did not constitute valid consideration under English law.
- It was found that the promise was made in a family context, giving rise to a presumption against an intention to create legal relations.
- The court determined there was no clear evidence of a legally binding agreement.
- The promise was regarded as too vague and lacking necessary specificity for contractual enforceability.
- The claim brought by Miss Pullan was dismissed.
Legal Principles
- Marriage consideration may constitute valid consideration if the promise is clear, specific, and intended to create legal relations.
- In family or domestic arrangements, there is a presumption against the intention to create legal relations.
- Moral or social obligations, without more, do not give rise to enforceable contracts.
- Clear evidence of intention and specificity of terms are required for contract formation, even in the context of marriage.
Conclusion
Pullan v Koe [1913] 1 Ch 9 clarified that promises made in contemplation of marriage require both a clear intention to create legal relations and specificity to be enforceable as contracts; mere moral obligations within a familial context are insufficient for legal enforcement.