Roe v Minister of Health [1954] 2 QB 66

Facts

  • The case involved an anaesthetist administering an anaesthetic to a patient using a glass ampoule stored in phenol solution for sterilization.
  • The ampoule had an invisible crack, causing phenol to seep into the anaesthetic and resulting in the patient’s paralysis.
  • The events took place in 1947, at which time the risk of contamination through invisible cracks was not recognized by the medical community.
  • The anaesthetist followed standard medical practices as understood in 1947.
  • Legal proceedings questioned whether the anaesthetist breached their duty of care by not detecting or preventing contamination based on the knowledge available at the time.

Issues

  1. Whether the standard of care owed by the medical professional should be assessed according to the knowledge and practices existing at the time of the incident.
  2. Whether the anaesthetist was negligent for failing to anticipate and prevent contamination of the anaesthetic, given the scientific understanding available in 1947.
  3. The extent to which a professional can be held liable for risks that were not, at the time, known or reasonably foreseeable.

Decision

  • The Court of Appeal found that the anaesthetist did not breach their duty of care.
  • The actions of the anaesthetist were judged by the state of knowledge in 1947, not by standards or discoveries made later.
  • The risk posed by invisible cracks in glass ampoules was not appreciated by the medical profession until 1951, after the incident.
  • The anaesthetist’s conduct conformed to the standard practices of the profession at the relevant time, so there was no negligence.
  • The Court ruled it is unfair and inappropriate to hold professionals to standards of knowledge or practice that emerged after the event.

Legal Principles

  • Negligence is evaluated according to the standard of a reasonably competent professional, assessed in light of the knowledge and practice prevailing at the time of the incident.
  • Professionals are not liable for failing to foresee risks that were not reasonably known or discoverable at the material time.
  • The standard of care is historically contextual, not retrospectively raised by later scientific or technical developments.
  • The principle applies broadly to professions whose knowledge and practices change over time, ensuring fairness and avoiding undue liability.
  • The temporal context of industry practices and scientific knowledge is a fundamental consideration in negligence law.

Conclusion

Roe v Minister of Health established that the standard of care in negligence is measured by the professional and scientific knowledge available at the time of the alleged breach. The anaesthetist was not negligent as the risk was undiscoverable with the means then known, and holding professionals to future standards would be unjust. This case underlines the importance of context and ongoing evolution of legal and professional standards.

The answers, solutions, explanations, and written content provided on this page represent PastPaperHero's interpretation of academic material and potential responses to given questions. These are not guaranteed to be the only correct or definitive answers or explanations. Alternative valid responses, interpretations, or approaches may exist. If you believe any content is incorrect, outdated, or could be improved, please get in touch with us and we will review and make necessary amendments if we deem it appropriate. As per our terms and conditions, PastPaperHero shall not be held liable or responsible for any consequences arising. This includes, but is not limited to, incorrect answers in assignments, exams, or any form of testing administered by educational institutions or examination boards, as well as any misunderstandings or misapplications of concepts explained in our written content. Users are responsible for verifying that the methods, procedures, and explanations presented align with those taught in their respective educational settings and with current academic standards. While we strive to provide high-quality, accurate, and up-to-date content, PastPaperHero does not guarantee the completeness or accuracy of our written explanations, nor any specific outcomes in academic understanding or testing, whether formal or informal.

Job & Test Prep on a Budget

Compare PastPaperHero's subscription offering to the wider market

PastPaperHero
Monthly Plan
$10
Assessment Day
One-time Fee
$20-39
Job Test Prep
One-time Fee
$90-350

Note the above prices are approximate and based on prices listed on the respective websites as of May 2025. Prices may vary based on location, currency exchange rates, and other factors.

Get unlimited access to thousands of practice questions, flashcards, and detailed explanations. Save over 90% compared to one-time courses while maintaining the flexibility to learn at your own pace.

All-in-one Learning Platform

Everything you need to master your assessments and job tests in one place

  • Comprehensive Content

    Access thousands of fully explained questions and cases across multiple subjects

  • Visual Learning

    Understand complex concepts with intuitive diagrams and flowcharts

  • Focused Practice

    Prepare for assessments with targeted practice materials and expert guidance

  • Personalized Learning

    Track your progress and focus on areas where you need improvement

  • Affordable Access

    Get quality educational resources at a fraction of traditional costs

Tell Us What You Think

Help us improve our resources by sharing your experience

Pleased to share that I have successfully passed the SQE1 exam on 1st attempt. With SQE2 exempted, I’m now one step closer to getting enrolled as a Solicitor of England and Wales! Would like to thank my seniors, colleagues, mentors and friends for all the support during this grueling journey. This is one of the most difficult bar exams in the world to undertake, especially alongside a full time job! So happy to help out any aspirant who may be reading this message! I had prepared from the University of Law SQE Manuals and the AI powered MCQ bank from PastPaperHero.

Saptarshi Chatterjee

Saptarshi Chatterjee

Senior Associate at Trilegal

The Integrated National Board Dental Examination (INBDE®), National Board Dental Hygiene Examination (NBDHE®), National Board Dental Examination (NBDE®, NBDE1®, NBDE2®) are programs of the Joint Commission on National Dental Examinations (JCNDE®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. The Multistate Bar Examination (MBE®) is a trademark of the National Conference of Bar Examiners (NCBE®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. The Medical College Admission Test (MCAT®) is a program of the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. The National Council Licensure Examination (NCLEX®, NCLEX-RN®, NCLEX-PN®) is a registered trademark of the National Council of State Boards of Nursing, Inc (NCSBN®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. The Solicitors Qualifying Examination (SQE1®, FLK1®, FLK2®) is a program of the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. The United Kingdom Medical Licensing Assessment (UKMLA®, AKT®) is a program of the General Medical Council (GMC®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. The United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE®, STEP1®, STEP2®) is a joint program of the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB®) and National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME®), which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, this product or site. The Project Management Professional (PMP®) is a registered trademark of the Project Management Institute, Inc. (PMI®), which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this product or site. All trademarks are registered trademarks of their respective holders. None of the trademark holders are affiliated with or endorse PastPaperHero or its products.

© 2025 PastPaperHero. All rights reserved.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. For more information please see our Privacy Policy.