Learning Outcomes
After studying this article, you will be able to explain the purpose of resource allocation and leveling in project planning, describe key methods for balancing workload and resolving resource conflicts, and apply principles of resource optimization for both predictive and agile projects. This knowledge will prepare you to analyze typical PMP scenarios involving resource constraints and scheduling.
PMP Syllabus
For PMP, you are required to understand how resources are planned, allocated, and managed within the project lifecycle. Ensure you can:
- Explain the process of identifying, assigning, and balancing project resources.
- Distinguish between resource allocation and resource leveling.
- Apply resource optimization techniques such as resource leveling and smoothing.
- Recognize impacts of resource constraints on project schedules.
- Analyze resource conflicts and propose effective solutions.
- Demonstrate understanding of agile team structures and flexibility in resource assignment.
- Use relevant tools like resource histograms and resource calendars to plan and control resources.
Test Your Knowledge
Attempt these questions before reading this article. If you find some difficult or cannot remember the answers, remember to look more closely at that area during your revision.
-
Which of the following best describes resource leveling in project management?
- Assigning more resources to critical path activities regardless of schedules
- Adjusting project schedules to resolve overallocations without altering resource usage
- Shortening project timelines by compressing tasks
- Recruiting additional team members for every delay
-
In an agile team who should decide who performs specific tasks on a project?
- Project sponsor
- Functional manager
- Project manager alone
- The team members collectively
-
What tool helps visualize resource usage to identify periods of over- or under-allocation?
- Milestone chart
- Resource histogram
- Product roadmap
- Cost baseline
Introduction
Resource allocation and leveling are essential aspects of project planning for delivering successful outcomes within time, budget, and quality constraints. All projects experience periods where demand for specific resources exceeds supply, or resources are underutilized. Effective planning requires project managers to ensure resources are scheduled appropriately and that conflicts are identified and resolved early. Understanding these techniques helps keep projects on schedule and within budget, while maintaining team motivation and workflow.
The Resource Planning Process
Resource planning starts with identifying what skills, roles, equipment, and materials are required to complete project deliverables. Project managers must consider both human and physical resources. In predictive projects, this often means assigning named individuals to schedule activities using resource calendars and a resource breakdown structure. In agile projects, cross-functional teams organize themselves to share and reassign responsibilities dynamically as work progresses.
Key Term: Resource Allocation
Assigning project resources (people, equipment, materials) to specific project tasks or activities based on requirements, schedule priorities, and availability.Key Term: Resource Leveling
A resource optimization technique that modifies the project schedule to address resource conflicts and overallocation, usually by delaying tasks until resources become available.
Causes of Resource Conflicts
Resource shortages can arise for several reasons:
- Multiple activities scheduled concurrently requiring the same resource (overallocation).
- Resource is scheduled for more than one project simultaneously.
- Non-working periods or planned absences.
- Delays or changes elsewhere in the project or organization.
Resource conflicts can quickly impact deadlines, costs, and team morale.
Techniques for Resource Allocation and Leveling
Step 1: Identify Resource Requirements
Begin with a resource breakdown structure (RBS) and identify types and quantities of all resources required for each project task or activity. Use resource calendars to check availabilities and constraints.
Step 2: Allocate Resources
Assign available resources to scheduled tasks considering skill requirements and workload balance. In agile, teams choose tasks themselves based on current capacity and skills.
Step 3: Detect and Resolve Overallocation
Use tools such as resource histograms to identify where a resource has been scheduled for more work than they can realistically complete. If overallocation exists, take corrective actions.
Step 4: Apply Resource Leveling
Resource leveling systematically adjusts start and finish dates, or even sequence of activities, so no resource exceeds their capacity. This may extend overall project duration, but ensures a feasible, realistic plan.
Step 5: Use Resource Smoothing (Where Appropriate)
Resource smoothing limits resource usage only within the flexibility (float) already available in the schedule, without extending the end date. Only tasks with float may be delayed.
Worked Example 1.1
A project manager assigns a specialist engineer to three overlapping tasks that together require 15 days in a single week. The engineer only has 5 working days that week. What must the project manager do?
Answer:
The engineer is overallocated. The project manager should apply resource leveling by delaying some activities until the engineer becomes available, negotiating task priorities, or seeking additional engineers if possible. If tasks are on the critical path, project completion may be delayed unless corrective actions are found.
Resource Histograms and Calendars
Resource histograms display resource usage over time and help visualize periods where a resource is overbooked or underutilized.
Key Term: Resource Histogram
A bar chart showing the amount of resource required for each time period, highlighting peaks or bottlenecks.
Calendars identify what resources are available at what times and any planned absences or non-working periods.
Key Term: Resource Calendar
A schedule that defines periods when specific people or equipment are available or unavailable for project work.
Resource Optimization in Agile Projects
Agile teams are typically stable, cross-functional, and self-organizing. Work assignments are made dynamically, with the team deciding who works on what based on capacity and skill. If bottlenecks occur, team members swarm on high-priority tasks.
Worked Example 1.2
An agile team has three developers, but one is absent for four days due to illness, affecting planned task completion. The remaining developers consider temporarily supporting the affected work. How does the team resolve this?
Answer:
The team self-organizes to redistribute tasks, possibly deferring less urgent work and pairing up where possible to share workload, keeping delivery on track despite reduced capacity.
Strategies for Resource Conflicts
When resource conflicts occur, consider:
- Re-prioritizing work packages or assignments.
- Delaying or splitting non-critical tasks to free resources.
- Bringing in additional resources (subject to budget constraints).
- Negotiating shared resources with functional managers.
Exam Warning
Resource leveling often leads to project duration increases. For PMP exam, do not assume you can resolve overallocation without affecting the schedule unless float or additional resources are available. Schedule impact is common.
Revision Tip
Before finalizing your project schedule, always run a resource histogram or leveling tool to check for hidden conflicts and avoid last-minute surprises on workload.
Summary
Resource allocation and leveling align resource usage with project demands and capacity, reducing overloads and bottlenecks. Effective methods include using resource histograms and calendars to identify issues, applying resource leveling to adjust schedules, and ensuring clear communication among project and functional managers. In agile, dynamic assignment and swarming help keep workflow smooth even with unexpected changes.
Key Point Checklist
This article has covered the following key knowledge points:
- Resource allocation assigns people, equipment, and materials to project work based on availability and skill.
- Resource leveling adjusts project schedules to resolve overallocation, usually by delaying tasks.
- A resource histogram helps visualize usage and identify overloads.
- Resource calendar documents when specific resources are available.
- Agile teams use dynamic, team-driven allocation with shared responsibility.
- Overallocated resources often require schedule changes or added support to resolve.
- Multi-project environments require careful coordination.
- Resource smoothing is an alternative where the project end date cannot change.
- Early detection of conflicts prevents disruption to project plans.
Key Terms and Concepts
- Resource Allocation
- Resource Leveling
- Resource Histogram
- Resource Calendar