## Facts

- The appellants were tenants of flats owned by Southwark London Borough Council.
- The flats were constructed with inadequate soundproofing, resulting in significant noise transmission between units.
- Tenants complained that everyday activities such as walking, talking, and using household appliances caused excessive noise, allegedly interfering with their quiet enjoyment of their homes.
- The tenants argued the council, as landlord, was responsible for improving the soundproofing to address the issue.
- Southwark LBC contended that the noise was consistent with normal household activities, not amounting to a legal nuisance, and asserted tenants must accept a reasonable degree of noise typical of communal living.

## Issues

1. Whether the noise generated by ordinary household activities in inadequately soundproofed flats constituted an actionable legal nuisance.
2. Whether Southwark LBC, as landlord, was responsible for rectifying noise transmission resulting from the normal occupancy and use of residential premises.
3. What standard should be applied to determine reasonableness in the context of noise nuisance in residential properties.

## Decision

- The House of Lords unanimously held that the noise complained of did not amount to a legal nuisance.
- The judgment clarified that normal household noise, such as that caused by everyday activities, is an inevitable consequence of communal living and must be tolerated.
- The court determined that landlords are not required to eliminate all noise transmission or improve soundproofing beyond basic standards of habitability.
- The standard for actionable nuisance is based on what an ordinary person would consider reasonable in the relevant circumstances.
- The tenants’ claims were dismissed.

## Legal Principles

- The tort of nuisance protects individuals from substantial and unreasonable interference with the use and enjoyment of land.
- Trivial or minor disturbances, especially those arising from normal residential activities, do not meet the legal threshold for nuisance.
- The principle of “give and take” means occupants in communal settings must accept some inconveniences as part of shared living.
- The reasonableness of noise is assessed objectively, reflecting the expectations of ordinary people in similar circumstances.
- Landlords are generally not liable for noise resulting from ordinary use of residential premises so long as adequate basic standards are met.

## Conclusion

The House of Lords confirmed that normal household noise in communal residential settings does not constitute a legal nuisance, establishing that tenants must tolerate reasonable noise levels, and clarified that landlords are not generally responsible for such interference provided basic standards are met. This case set a clear standard for noise nuisance and continues to guide the balance between individual rights and communal responsibilities in residential environments.


Southwark LBC v Mills [1999] 4 All ER 449